Home » Comcast/Xfinity »Consumer News » Currently Reading:

Comcast Moving Away from Customer Retention Discounts for Cable TV

Phillip Dampier February 11, 2019 Comcast/Xfinity, Consumer News No Comments

Despite the growing impact of cord-cutting, Comcast is following companies like Charter Spectrum by cutting back customer retention discounts that savvy subscribers negotiate to keep their cable bill reasonable. Despite losing more than 344,000 cable television customers in 2018, almost twice as many as it lost in 2017, Comcast has lost interest in cutting prices to keep customers.

Traditionally, customers using the word “cancel” with a customer service representative would quickly be offered deeply discounted service if they agreed to stay. Customers willing to stand their ground in tough negotiations with the cable company could win promotional pricing indefinitely, often saving several hundred dollars a year without losing channels or services. In 2016, after Charter Communications completed its merger with Time Warner Cable and Bright House Networks, Charter CEO Thomas Rutledge vowed to impose “pricing discipline” on Time Warner Cable’s “Turkish bazaar of promotional deals” after Charter took control of the company.

Rutledge called out the ‘madness’ of offering customers fire sale prices on internet and television service at a MoffettNathanson Media & Communications Summit in May 2017.

“Time Warner wanted to make a video number, and there were data packages that cost less if you took video than if you didn’t,” Rutledge said. “And a lot of those were churning out. And a lot of them were basic-only. So on the margin, at the end – in the last year, I think they were selling 40% of their connects as basic-only. [TWC had] 90,000 different promotional offers, many of them deeply discounted and piled on top of each other.”

Rutledge said Time Warner Cable represented the worst of an industry practice that gave unprecedented power to customers to get what they wanted, at least for awhile.

“You’d call in, bargain … And so there’s a lot of that out there. And they’re also exploding packages. Meaning, at the end of the term, they go back to full price,” Rutledge complained.

Rutledge called an end to negotiations by offering customers the opportunity of keeping their current package, but gradually raising it to a price that was often higher than Spectrum’s own non-negotiable packages and pricing. Regardless of what package a customer chose, it was a win for Charter because regular pricing ensured the company was making money either way.

Comcast has apparently been won over by Rutledge’s message to the industry and is now gradually moving in a similar direction.


Matt Strauss, executive vice president of XFINITY Services, told Business Insider Comcast will now attempt to keep and win back its cord-cutting customers not by discounting prices, but by creating much smaller cable TV packages with fewer channels — a practice known as slimming down packages into “skinny bundles.” Comcast also plans to stop pushing customers into its “best value” triple-play packages of television, phone, and internet services, understanding many customers have no interest in some of those services.

“Our strategy is very focused on segmentation and getting more sophisticated in putting together the right video offering for the right customer at the right time in their life,” Strauss said, not by offering deep discounts on bloated packages (including a landline or hundreds of unwanted TV channels) that would reduce profitability.

Charter is already offering an ultra-slim, a-la-carte local TV package combining Music Choice with the customer’s pick of 10 national cable channels for $21.99 a month. The package is targeted to those with internet-only service and is accessed through a Roku set-top box. DVR service is available, if a customer was willing to pay a steep DVR service and box rental fee.

Comcast’s new strategy will market internet packages that include the added-cost option of a super-slim TV package of local channels and a handful of cable networks.

Strauss disagrees with some industry pundits who have suggested cable companies are planning to abandon selling cable television altogether in favor of internet-only service.

“We continue to be very bullish on video, but you’re just going to see us be more focused on how we go to market with video,” Strauss said.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Search This Site:


Recent Comments:

  • Sean: Whenever my internet + TV promo bundle is up for expiration at Comcast, I explain that I only need the internet service. But the rep will aways offer...
  • Paul Houle: If this is how they think, let Charter buy them. This is really a bluff to fool the decision-making class: it might help them in negotiations with ...
  • pali792000: New to the site, I have Verizon DSL in my area. Verizon and TWC are the only internet provides here in Los Angeles, CA. The Best speed I get is .79 mb...
  • gregcols: As usual looks like Columbus will not get these possible upgrades for several years...yet we are getting charged out the ass for unreliable service....
  • Smith6612: As much as I used to dislike having the cable ck.pang throw their weight around in the past, I find myself rooting for Time Warner and the upgrades to...
  • I LOVE JESUS!.: Time Warner needs to hurry and bring the 100Mbps to Ohio....
  • Hugh Wardlaw: Voip may be nice. During a power outage will it work? It probably won't during a disaster when power is lost. I haven't seen a cell phone that can sen...
  • Ian L: Hopefully Austin gets these upgrades sooner rather than later. With GFiber there'll certainly be the competitive reason for it (WiFi everywhere is gre...
  • Sebastian Taraska: This deal works great but should be updated for price increase, I got 24 Mbps for 35.50 for 1yr....
  • MaximusMMIV: I just have this lingering, sad thought that TWC will never have the opportunity to actually make this happen. They've spent way too many years abusin...
  • Mike: WOW this would be fantastic...if they survive the takeover. Would probably be next year before the upgrade makes it to western NY but it sounds very n...
  • Michael Elling (@Infostack): TWC guide interface in NYC didn't improve. If anything it got worse! Many simple steps simply disappeared, like trying to record a future showing of...

Your Account:

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
Stop the Cap!