Home » Charter Spectrum »Consumer News »Public Policy & Gov't »Rural Broadband » Currently Reading:

N.Y. Gives Charter Spectrum Another Extension

Phillip Dampier November 26, 2018 Charter Spectrum, Consumer News, Public Policy & Gov't, Rural Broadband 12 Comments

New York’s Department of Public Service (DPS) has granted Charter Communications an unprecedented additional 18-day extension to file its threatened appeal of the Commission’s decision to boot the cable company from the state and its six-month exit plan.

“Charter and DPS Staff state in their request for a limited 18-day extension of time that discussions are ongoing, that Charter and DPS Staff have established a framework for how a settlement agreement might be structured, and that any final agreement would necessarily address: issues relating to the inclusion of certain categories of addresses and whether they are valid ‘passings’ under the Merger Approval Order; penalty actions and amounts under dispute in Supreme Court; and a schedule for compliance (including enforcement mechanisms) going forward,” the order granting the extension reads.

Despite last week’s filing from Charter’s attorneys excoriating the Public Service Commission for its decision to remove Spectrum from the state, the DPS claimed this week that because of Charter’s “continued obligations to comply with the Public Service Law and regulations, good cause exists […] to allow for further discussions while both sides reserve their respective legal rights.”

But some consumer groups, including Stop the Cap!, are wondering exactly when patience will run thin at the Commission.

“When the latest deadline arrives in January 2019, it will be nearly six months since the Commission voted to strip approval of Charter’s merger with Time Warner Cable,” said Phillip M. Dampier, founder of Stop the Cap! “While we can appreciate the benefits of negotiation and dialogue, these conversations are taking place behind closed doors with no public input and no formal ability for groups like ours to intervene and offer our own views.”

Stop the Cap! has advocated that Charter Communications be allowed to remain in business in New York, but only with their agreement to meet some additional terms and conditions:

  1. Further extend Spectrum service to additional customers in rural New York scheduled to receive satellite internet service;
  2. Increase entry-level broadband speed to at least 200 Mbps immediately and further extend availability of Everyday Low Price Internet service ($14.99/mo);
  3. Settle the ongoing labor dispute with striking Spectrum workers in downstate New York.

“At present, it appears the DPS/PSC is only negotiating to get Spectrum back in compliance with the original terms of the Merger Order they have been ignoring, which is hardly a concession,” Dampier said. “Charter’s arrogance and blatant disrespect for the terms of the merger deal and its flippant adherence to those terms should cost the company more than just a monetary fine lost in the state’s coffers. Visible benefits to New York consumers must be part of the equation.”

Dampier

The state seems mostly focused on keeping Charter in compliance with the agreement while the lawyers talk.

“As the Commission noted in prior extensions, however, this limited extension should not be viewed as an indefinite grant of time for discussions to continue between DPS Staff and the Company,” DPS officials wrote. “Many Upstate New Yorkers living in Charter’s franchise areas are understandably frustrated by the lack of modern communications infrastructure. The Compliance and Revocation Orders were designed to deal with very serious consumer issues presented by Charter’s conduct related to the company’s network expansion. As such, the processes envisioned therein must continue in the absence of an agreement.”

The current extension resets the deadlines to file an appeal to Dec. 14, 2018 and the six-month exit plan to Jan. 11, 2019. Both are just the latest in a series of extensions.

Important Dates:

  • July 27, 2018: The PSC votes to rescind approval of the Charter/Time Warner Cable merger in New York, effectively disallowing the company to continue to do business in the state.
  • August 17, 2018: Charter files a 60-day extension request, which is granted on Aug. 20.
  • September 7, 2018: Charter files a 30-day extension request, which is granted on Sept. 10.
  • October 9, 2018: Charter files a 60-day extension request. The DPS grants a 45-day extension instead on Oct. 10.
  • November 21, 2018: Department of Public Service (DPS) Staff and Charter filed a joint letter stating that they had not yet been able to reach a fully executed settlement agreement, but that they had established a framework for how a settlement agreement might be structured and that discussions remain ongoing. A limited 18-day extension is granted.
  • December 14, 2018: Deadline for Charter to file its appeal with the Commission.
  • January 11, 2019: Deadline for Charter to file a six-month exit plan showing the Commission how the company intends to orderly transfer its Spectrum cable operation to another provider.

12
Leave a Reply

avatar
11 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
10 Comment authors
Willie C BranaganDamien ThomasJohnEarlPaul Houle Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Ms Willie C Branagan
Guest
Ms Willie C Branagan

I have sent complaints regarding Spectrum to the FCC, New York State’s Attorney General, always with copies to Thomas M. Rutledge CEO and President, Charter Communications. However, despite the fact that I have spoken to no one who feels that Spectrum provides even fair service. I am sorry that they continue to receive extensions.

Dylan
Guest
Dylan

I definitely see this whole ordeal just stalling for quite a while and going quietly in the night. NYS has no options here besides Charter.

Dylan
Guest
Dylan

I will add as my edit time ran out that I agree here with mostly everything said. Most importantly, getting 200mbps base standard to everyone and making sure everyone has the best equipment aka, the new 3.1 modems. The older legal matters with the attorney general were mostly due to bad customer equipment and/or older equipment from legacy TWC. Now that Spectrum carries some very good equipment, wave two router 2200mbps total throughput and Docsis 3.1 modems for all, there should be no issues for speed.

Vince
Guest
Vince

Just a quick bit of food for thought. Everyone always complains about spectrum being a horrible provider. You guys unfortunately are not seeing the big picture. What do you think happens when they leave NY. You are going to get a 100x worse replacement Comcast coming in to replace. This is going to be the biggest IT cluster of all time. Spectrum, yes, is not the best ISP and they have their issues. But they are light years better than Comcast. There shouldn’t be a push to remove them. There should be a push to introduce competition. Everyone who supports… Read more »

Damien Thomas
Guest
Damien Thomas

I disagree…I recently moved back here to Rochester (my hometown) from portland Oregon- my first time out west- and they have comcast which has Xfinity…Xfinity is a far superior service than spectrum equipment wise, stability wise as well as stability in its pricing. I am now a spectrum customer and it is a living nightmare compared to time warner and Xfinity. I feel like I’m being raped as a consumer and theres nothing I can do about it. Meanwhile the state legislators are basically saying if they give the politicians enough money they can do what they want with our… Read more »

Justin
Guest
Justin

Yup, spectrum is the lesser of two evils.

EJ
Guest
EJ

It is about principle and holding a companies feet to the fire. As long as the government rolls over they will continue to get rolled over. Funny how the talk was tough around election time and now it is well okay we will give you an extension. I don’t care how it is done, but the company should be kicked out. Take the money from the fines and turn it into a municipality. All the matters is getting them out. I’m so sick of telecommunication companies getting away with promising things they don’t deliver. FEET TO THE FIRE!!!!!!!!

Ian S Littman
Guest
Ian S Littman

The issue here is that the NY PSC’s threats have no teeth because, well, who will take over the cable systems if Spectrum is forced to sell? Either Altice or Comcast, and Altice probably can’t outbid Comcast for the properties. Heck, Comcast could offer Spectrum a market swap so no money would change hands, kind of like what happened years ago when Adelphia was pieced out. For example, Comcast could give Spectrum its Texas (Houston-area), North Carolina, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, Kansas, and/or Missouri systems in exchange for Spectrum’s NYC systems, at which point each cable company would end up with a… Read more »

Paul Houle
Guest
Paul Houle

For a long time communities have been frustrated in that they don’t have any power to
negotiate with cable companies.

This town refused to enter into a contract with “big cable”

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/12/comcast-rejected-by-small-town-residents-vote-for-municipal-fiber-instead/

probably because they’ve seen that a contract protects the cable company but not the town.

If New York really wants universal service in upstate they just may need to take “the public option”.

Earl
Guest
Earl

Stop with the extensions… spectrum is a price/speed manipulating scam company..I’m in upstate NY Albany county..I pay $71 a month for internet only…it’s the only option I have where I live…so spectrum can charge me anything they want…it’s garbage..it doesn’t work half the time n have to keep unplugging n replugging it in…handful of calls..the answer is always…well concrete walls..microwaves will affect it…are you kidding me?. Garbage company garbage answers…kick them out!!!

John
Guest
John

I have been with Time Warner since the 1980’s and since Charter Spectrum took over here in upstate NY my internet only minimum speed bill went from 29.99 to recently raised to 59.99. I am retired living on a fixed income and no one is giving me a raise. Yet companies like Spectrum and other utilities just keep raising their rates. I complained and got a small reduction only because I have been with RR and them since the beginning and have never been late paying my bill. But people HAVE TO draw the line if they don’t they will… Read more »

Willie C Branagan
Guest
Willie C Branagan

iI am continually repulsed by the fact that (WEAK) New York State’s Attorney General keeps providing Spectrum with extensions. They are not going to change, and my most recent bill just increased almost $20. They are a joke; advertise for business customers and now their cell/wireless services. I watch C-SPAN, I’m not allowed any exterior “gadgets” where I live, so I am a captive audience/customer. I’ve tried, but to no avail. Letters I’ve sent to the AT are only forward to Spectrum for their scripted response.

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • Ken: I've started a Facebook group, https://www.facebook.com/groups/xFinityDataUsage/, to try and fight back. There's no reasonable explanation for the dat...
  • Ken: Hi, I've started a Facebook group, https://www.facebook.com/groups/xFinityDataUsage/, as many folks are like myself finding we are getting overages wh...
  • waldo Barnes: Hate those Rats...
  • John C. Hall: What you say is still true, in 2020. Our home phone service is very high and they offer only 1 home phone package. To drop the home phone line and k...
  • Kenneth: I want to sue them for abandoning my system and my investment in it....
  • Phillip Dampier: The thing about this policy change is that it appeared as a cryptic bill notice buried on a single invoice mixed in with lots of other notices. Most p...
  • Phillip Dampier: They turn you over to collections and potentially hit your credit. Your score will probably drop by more than 20 points and this will stay on your rep...
  • Phillip Dampier: If they admit you returned your equipment, you should be able to cancel this bill. If they don't help you by phone, file a BBB complaint online. If yo...
  • Phillip Dampier: You may live in a state where pro-rating is mandatory. Also, you transferred your account, which means it remained open, only the accountholder's name...
  • Dee McCarthy: Spectrum is trash sent us a bill weeks after we gave back boxes and had stopped service since beginning of the year...Our bill was zero then we got a ...
  • Gwen Brown: They are charging me $230 a month .No HBO, NO STARZ, NO SHOWTIME? ?...
  • Roux Oli: The system worked just fine. As a matter of fact, as a former Technician for TWC/Spectrum, we were installing new systems not very long ago. Asking pe...

Your Account: