Home » Broadband "Shortage" »Comcast/Xfinity »Data Caps »Online Video »Video » Currently Reading:

Capped Comcast Customers Play Columbo to Identify Data Hogging Services

Phillip Dampier March 27, 2018 Broadband "Shortage", Comcast/Xfinity, Data Caps, Online Video, Video 11 Comments

Nathan Gray woke up one morning this month and received an alarming notification from Comcast, his internet provider, claiming he had exceeded his Comcast terabyte data cap and was being billed an additional $10 for a 50 GB allotment of extra data.

“This has never happened before and I was only six days into my monthly billing cycle, so I assumed it must be a mistake,” Gray told Stop the Cap! “But Comcast told me it wasn’t a mistake.”

Gray was hardly alone. One month earlier, “Bogreenwoo” discovered his family had blown the roof off their internet usage, exceeding 1 TB by the middle of the billing cycle, with more usage piling up hour after hour.

“Xfinity was adding 50 GB blocks every day at $10 each and calls to tech support were no help,” he shared on Comcast’s customer support forum.

Similar complaints are brought up on that forum at least weekly, if not more often. Comcast counterclaims that usage exceeding 1 TB a month is so rare, it represents only about 1% of its customer base. But customers with huge internet bills from Comcast who stumble their way to the company’s support forum strongly dispute that notion.

“Well good luck with finding a solution or even finding anyone at Comcast who cares or anyone anywhere else as far as that goes,” shared “Amaasing.” “I have had this issue more than once and have talked with every vice president of customer service and had discussions with the security department and even filed a complaint with the FCC and nothing happened at all.”

Some users, like Amaasing, have received so many bills stung with overlimit fees they now turn their computers off in the evening and unplug their cable modems. In many cases the usage keeps rising anyway.

“Today when I logged in, I had apparently used 196 GB yesterday,” Amaasing wrote. “196 GB in 24 hours?  Seriously?”

For most customers in this predicament, Comcast is quick to blame customers for the usage and leave the detective work up to them. Customer support will not entertain suggestions their usage meter is inaccurate. In their view, it is more likely someone is illicitly connected to your Wi-Fi and stealing your service or you are running some bandwidth-heavy application or your computer has been hijacked by hackers or pirates.

While you are left to investigate which of these might be true, Comcast is free to continue billing your account overlimit fees.

Comcast claims it will forgive customers who exceed their data allowance twice ‘a year’:

“We’ll provide you with two courtesy months, so you will not be billed the first two times you exceed a terabyte while you are getting used to the new data usage plan. This means that you will only be subject to overage charges if you use more than a terabyte for a third time in a 12-month period. If you use more than a terabyte two times or less in a 12-month period, your courtesy month balance will reset to two at the end of these 12 months. However, if you use more than a terabyte three times in a 12-month period, no more courtesy months will be given.”

After “courtesy months” expire, you are on the hook for whatever excess usage Comcast determines you have consumed. Some Comcast customers assume the courtesy month counter resets each calendar year, but in fact it only resets after 12 consecutive months of staying within your allowance limit.

What causes “excess usage” is anyone’s guess. Comcast customers have documented several recent causes why they have mysteriously started blowing through their 1 TB data allowance:

  1. The growing prevalence of 4K video, the highest streaming video quality available through online video streaming services can be responsible for a sudden spike of usage. Netflix and other services that support 4K video content with high dynamic range can eat up 7 GB to 10 GB of data per hour. Many services allow you to downgrade your video settings with minimal quality loss. We recommend trying settings typically labeled 720 or 1080 — the lower the better if you are running up against your allowance.
  2. Third party backup and cloud storage tools: That online backup or cloud storage service you are using may be malfunctioning. There are several reports about Amazon Drive having problems recently, causing files to be repeatedly transferred and driving up usage to several hundred gigabytes a day in some cases. If you use Amazon Drive and have seen a huge spike in usage, try uninstalling or turning off the service for several days and see if usage falls dramatically. Other file and computer backup services that store your data in the cloud can consume a lot of data, especially when installing them on a new computer for the first time. Even some cell phone backup services designed to store your photos in the cloud can malfunction and repeatedly try to send the same photos over and over. Disable these tools for several days and check your usage levels.
  3. Third party usage: Family members doing something bandwidth intensive can also be responsible for dramatic usage spikes. Although downloading video game updates can consume very large amounts of data, game play itself typically has little impact on your data usage. Check with family members to see if they are watching high bandwidth video or have installed a file backup service. Less common is an uninvited guest on your Wi-Fi network. Comcast often points to Wi-Fi security as a major problem when a neighbor gains access to your internet connection to download huge numbers of files. You can change your Wi-Fi password to help lock down your network. Make sure not to use plain word passwords — use a mixture of letters, numbers, and symbols.
  4. Comcast’s meter is simply inaccurate. There is no independent third-party verification or government oversight of Comcast’s usage meter. Most ISPs hire a third-party contractor to design and implement their data measurement meters, but those contractors are ultimately answerable to the provider — not to you, giving little peace of mind to consumers who are forced to trust their cable company to be honest. Our country’s Founding Fathers placed great importance on accurate measuring and weighing tools, so much so it is addressed in Section VIII of Article I of the U.S. Constitution. That section gives authority to Congress to establish accurate and regulated measurement tools. Each state has their own way of managing this, often with a bureau of weights and measurements that independently verifies and certifies — with a tamper-evident sticker, the accuracy of the food scale at your local grocer or the gas pump at a nearby service station. Comcast has resisted similar third-party oversight for its usage meter. But considering the company’s overlimit fees can add a substantial sum to customer bills, having this kind of oversight seems appropriate.

Avoiding the usage cap: Comcast ironically provides its own insurance plan to protect customers from its own arbitrary data allowance. For peace of mind, Comcast collects an extra $50 a month ($20 for gigabit speed DOCSIS 3.1 plans) if you wish to waive the data cap altogether. Data caps are completely under the control of Comcast and are especially prevalent in regions of the country where a lack of competition exists. But Comcast’s arguments in favor of data caps don’t wash at the nation’s second largest cable company – Charter Communications, which markets its internet service as having no data caps at all. In fact, Charter CEO Thomas Rutledge never saw much use for data caps at Charter or Cablevision, the company he used to head.

Debunking arguments for usage caps at Comcast and other ISPs. (5:46)

11
Leave a Reply

avatar
11 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
jayDonald SchoonerJoshAmyDavid Tybor Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Straypuft
Guest
Straypuft

Single person household here who views streaming tv daily, I exceed that 1TB every month(About 1.5TB/mo), Luckily Im with Spectrum so no cap, but that $50 unlimited fee with Comcast only seems like a family tax as I fail to see how a household of 4 could keep their internet usage under 1TB monthly.

ADubb
Guest
ADubb

I completely agree with the comment above. I go over my limit each month, have a few Nest cams and cloud back up devices on my home network. Something needs to be done about this new “mandatory” tax on subscribers. Especially those of us who signed on with no caps in our contracts.

Kim
Guest
Kim

I am having this exact same problem. Our internet usage doubled in one month… not slowly grew… doubled! I have been fighting them about this for months! I’m getting nowhere. So frustrating. I told them this is like the water company saying ‘go ahead and turn the water on but you can’t control the flow or see where it’s going or how you are using it… we’ll just funnel it behind this fence and bill you for it” . There is no way to control it if you can’t tell me how we are using it~!

Jessie B
Guest
Jessie B

Same! And there is NO WAY I used that up in 2 weeks. Just paid my bill!
But…there is a profit motive so I’m sure its some sort of scheme. And ironically comcast is all we can get in my apartment complex….isnt that a monopoly? And so convenient.

Brent
Guest
Brent

I’m having the exact same issue. I got a notification on my phone through the xfinity app (At 1am in the morning) that I have gone over my data limit. I look at our usage and their graphs show it doubled in February and March from what it was in January and December. It said we almost hit the limit in February but now that I’ve gone over I find out. There is no explanation for this.

I can only get Comcast as well, no way has my usage doubled, this is total garbage!

Wayne
Guest
Wayne

Comcast is known for its shady billing practices. The FCC has finally started to hit them with hefty fines. I urge everyone who is having a problem to file a report with the FCC. Hopefully after enough complaints they will stop fining them and start an investigation. Silence accomplishes nothing.

David Tybor
Guest
David Tybor

My family of 4 has Comcast and we go over every month. We cut the cable chord years ago., We stream local and cable channels through Playstation Vue. We also have Netflix and Hulu. Since all TV (including commercials) is streamed… it’s really easy to go over…. and all 4 of us are gone 8am to 5pm from the house with school and work most days. I don’t consider myself a heavy TV watcher so I can only imagine the data usage for those that are stay at home’s or the like. I’ve banned 4K streaming and all PS4 games… Read more »

Amy
Guest
Amy

It’s such a scam. According to Comcast data we were using 1.5TB month, Even though we have unlimited phones through Verizon. I refused to pay and now we use just our phones and we each use about 30gb a month for 4 people about 120GB and that’s connecting them to our TV’s and streaming netfliz, Amazon prime and Hulu. Same as before.

Josh
Guest
Josh

Modem loophole?

I went to check my usage, and my account doesn’t list the metering at all. I have an older 3rd party modem, Netgear CM500-100NAS, I’m guessing the modem doesn’t support tracking the metering? I think I may have “unlimited” internet by accident.

Is anyone else experiencing this?

Donald Schooner
Guest
Donald Schooner

i used 100gb in two days with my router and tv box unplugged from the wall. I switched to AT&T fiber.

jay
Guest
jay

im also under the impression that its a scam, comcast has me shown at 1.3k gigs used in the last 30 days. my computer has me shown at 150gigs used in the last 30 days, with my computer being the only thing connected to the internet.

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • WHE: Just an FYI. A few days ago, I downgraded my Internet service from ultra to standard and they pro-rated my bill. Maybe I got lucky, but I suspect they...
  • Joe: You never bought into it, yet here you are posting comments via the Internet....
  • Jason Paiva: Yea, DOESNT WORK! I've spent years and dozens if attempts at plugging in my info, being told it could take 45-60days and continuing to get mailers. ...
  • pug: Spectrum just raised our rate from 65.99 to 69.99 here in southern Oregon for internet only. Price gouging extortionists!...
  • Nick: The coax shield might be grounded lower down, close to where it enters the house....
  • Tom: That is very bad business..cancelled my cable tv 2 days in of the billing cycle and told me I would have to pay for the services for the entire month....
  • B Woods: The image at the top of the article is a failed install. No #10 copper ground/bonding wire for lightning protection. Insurance company’s love t...
  • Amestris: You should enter your address online and see if it comes up. I was told I didn't qualify either but when I looked on their website I in fact did. My f...
  • Stuart Matelsky: Stay away from altice if you know what is good. They take your money, thats it...
  • Stuart Matelsky: Stay away unless you have low blood pressure...
  • Jonathan Wood: Nice. So instead of wireline broadband like they promised in NY, I'm sure they're going to start pushing this wireless crap as "last mile fixes" for p...
  • Steve Copeland: I got a $32 a month increase with no notice or explanation. $384/yr increase....

Your Account: