Home » Astound »Broadband Speed »Comcast/Xfinity »Competition »Consumer News »Data Caps »Editorial & Site News » Currently Reading:

Not Only Was Comcast’s Customer Retentions Guy Annoying, He Was Also Factually Wrong

astound-broadband-logoNearly two million people have listened to the Comcast customer service call from hell since it went viral earlier this week.

Comcast quickly decided it was best to apologize:

We are very embarrassed by the way our employee spoke with Mr. Block and Ms. Belmont and are contacting them to personally apologize. The way in which our representative communicated with them is unacceptable and not consistent with how we train our customer service representatives. We are investigating this situation and will take quick action. While the overwhelming majority of our employees work very hard to do the right thing every day, we are using this very unfortunate experience to reinforce how important it is to always treat our customers with the utmost respect.

csrSetting aside all that, we decided to investigate why Mr. Block was willing to subject himself to 18 minutes of phone hell to cancel his service.

At one point, we learn he is switching to Astound, a provider of cable TV, broadband internet, and telephone services on the West Coast, serving over 325,000 residential and business customers within communities in the San Francisco Bay area. Astound is an overbuilder, which means it is one of those rare instances where Comcast faces head to head competition with a company that can deliver more than DSL.

Although Comcast’s rep swore Comcast had the fastest Internet speeds (it doesn’t) and can deliver maximum savings (also wrong), it turns out Astound offers both cheaper and faster Internet service. We’d probably switch too, although we wish Astound would dump its 1TB monthly usage cap. How many customers even come close to that isn’t known, but it is likely under 1%, which makes us wonder why they bother with a cap at all?

We collected pricing information from both Astound and Comcast’s websites and here is what we found:

Stop the Cap! will include this incident in our formal filings with the FCC and New York State Public Service Commission in opposition to the merger of Time Warner Cable and Comcast. Comcast customers tell us Mr. Block’s experiences, although extreme, are not uncommon when dealing with Comcast’s customer retention department.

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Dave Hancock
Guest
Dave Hancock

But according to the Consumer Report’s sister site, “The Consumerist”, this was entirely normal (even encouraged) behavior: http://consumerist.com/2014/07/16/comcast-employees-say-needy-retention-call-is-totally-normal/ Some of the interest items in that article are: “Meanwhile, Consumerist has heard from Comcast call center workers both past and present who agree that maybe while this guy went a bit far, it’s only because that’s the culture at the company, and that customer service reps are actually trained to do just what he did.” and: “That rep, (may God have mercy on his soul) was doing exactly as he was told to do,” writes former Comcast call center employee and… Read more »

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • L. Nova: The entire company board needs to be ousted....
  • Noemi Najera: I would LOVE to join any class action suit against Spectrum....
  • Tommy: Directv has just joined my group of the worst companies in the US. That includes ComCast and Capitol 1. Awful customer service and can't get anything ...
  • jeff: As an average consumer, I don't understand the technical aspect of your answer. Can you explain in simple terms how I can improve the wifi coverage an...
  • Lee: Only useful if you have cable. 13 houses in 0.6 miles from where cable stops to my house. Comcast shows no interest in extending the cable....
  • Peter: Call Spectrum. They will tell you the $9.99 is a "mailing fee" for ordering their equipment, not an installation fee. In a calm voice tell them you ne...
  • Michael Gibbons: it would just be nice if the stupid FRONTIER telephone company would just go out of business once and for all.. THEY ARE JUST ABOUT WORTHLESS. Like yo...
  • HatinComcast: Agreed, I’m in a huge fight with them about this issue....
  • Doug: Grandfathered in does not mean not subject to price increases. It means you will be able to stay on the plan at whatever the prevailing price is as l...
  • Sum: What kind of internet for low income is it, DSL or Wireless internet?...
  • Janessa: Shame on you Spectrum. Grandfathered in means grandfathered in. That should be honored at the price committed to on the contract signed. It clearly st...
  • James R Curry: Most of the ISPs have now done this. AT&T and Comcast are the biggest offenders and have. So, the ISPs argued that data caps were necessary beca...

Your Account: