Home » Comcast/Xfinity »Data Caps »Editorial & Site News »Video » Currently Reading:

Man Cut Off for a Year for Exceeding Comcast’s 250GB Cap-Story Going Viral

Phillip Dampier July 18, 2011 Comcast/Xfinity, Data Caps, Editorial & Site News, Video 13 Comments

[flv width=”640″ height=”380″]http://www.phillipdampier.com/video/KOMO Seattle Man Loses Internet for a Year 7-14-11.mp4[/flv]

Last week, Stop the Cap! shared the story of Andre Vrignaud, a 39-year-old gaming consultant in Seattle who found his Comcast Internet service shut off for a year for twice exceeding the company’s arbitrary 250GB usage cap.  The story continues to draw media attention, including this TV news report from Seattle station KOMO-TV.  Cloud computing is implicated, but Vrignaud’s cure — paying more for additional usage, strikes us as the wrong answer.  Monetizing broadband usage is a provider’s dream come true.  The better solution would be to fight to remove the cap or at least ensure residential customers can upgrade to business service, if they choose, without the year-long “ban” in place.  (3 minutes)

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Scott
Guest
Scott

Regular broadband users need to hear this story to understand it’s not the “1%” of users as claimed that are getting slapped with overages or having service cut, everyone is affected.

Even with providers like Comcast that’s hundreds and thousands of people having to pay large fees or face assinine policies.

Ben
Guest
Ben

Glad the news team blew up the spot saying this guy is now stealing Internet off a neighbors network. Comcast can now monitor that and charge him with Theft of Service and slap him with a HUGE fine!

siouxmoux
Guest

Comcast Should adopt ATT Business plan. If you go over 150gig dsl or 250gig vdsl data caps they will charge you $10 for every 50gig. Comcast is missing out in this hugh cash cow, Anyone notice this guy owns one those twitting scales, the same one Leo Laporte owns.

Alex Perrier
Guest
Alex Perrier

That is 10¢ per GB, a rate at which they still make a significant amount of profit. Ever heard of TekSavvy, a Canadian Internet service provider? They charge $31.95/month for their 300 GB DSL plan at 5 Mbit/s. That’s exactly 10.65¢/GB.

UPDATE: Cheaper by the Cable. At $27.95/month, TekSavvy’s 3 Mbit/s offering includes 300 GB per month. That’s less than 9.32¢/GB, a lower rate at which the company still makes a reasonable profit.

Ben
Guest
Ben

Well, then here is my beef. If they force “Consumption Based Billing” then the FCC should IMMEDIATELY REQUIRE ALA CARTE CABLE! They can’t have it both ways. They say subs should only pay for what they use – fine. Then we should only pay for what channels we want too.

jr
Guest
jr

Brian Roberts makes 31 million while his customers are only supposed to use their internet account for emailing birthday wishes to their relatives

Duffin
Guest
Duffin

I am still amazed that there is more outcry for netflix raising their prices slightly than there is for ISPs pulling stuff like this. I don’t buy that customers “agreed” to it, as they said. This guy said he had Comcast for 8 years. The cap policy is apparently only something like three years old. So, he was forced into agreeing to it. I’m assuming there are no alternative ISPs or he would have just switched. So, that means that the customer was essentially forced into accepting the caps with no alternative. That’s some crap right there…

Richard
Guest
Richard

If the FCC wants America to survive in the 21st century and they want to keep their lobbyists happy it can be done. Take away all franchise agreements for Comcast et al that impose caps on their users. If they don’t want to share their lines yes this goes for you Verizon FIOS that is fine. Any third party that wants to build fiber networks to compete with them should be allowed to do so. Those networks should be open access and the users should own their own lines even if they don’t pay to have them instaled. I wonder… Read more »

Richard
Guest
Richard

I don’t disagree with Google being one of the few who has the power to directly challenge ISPs on their own turf. I may be wrong but I do believe that Docscis 3 has a 100 mbps symmetric limit per user if it is not oversold. Cut that in half if it is over sold. Time Warner thinks that 20 mbps down 2 mbps up is worth an extra $20, I say hell no. The reason that Google may not want to expand is not only the money involved, but the rules and regulations that the ISPs and government have… Read more »

Richard
Guest
Richard

There’s a long pdf that explains why the communities that are able to deploy ftth muni networks should. We’ll see what happens after our next Presidential election. We’ll see if we head down the path that South Korea et al have taken. Or if we head down the path of Canada and other heavily capped and sensored countries.

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • Michael Ware: I know this is a old comment I don't even know what you're talking about because when I had charter I didn't pay a lot of money and I never had any is...
  • Jean Grubbs: They don't know how to fix the problem know more...
  • kim smith: they r ridiculous,shut of service with a bill of 112.00 and they charged me 450.00 ,im not paying it,i didnt re sign a contract for 2 years and that's...
  • David L Walls: I just changed to Suddenlink, TV, Internet and phone,, simply because of cost AND the fact Frontier intends to make a Customer sign a four year contra...
  • RETIRED SEI: Join the discussion...I did some research on this. I retired 3 months ago. I just submitted paper work for lump sum for Jan 2020. If Frontier goes BK ...
  • Eric Hartman: Enjoy your 3 months increase from me because come spring im getting rid of it....
  • Barry: The only thing that surprises me about this is that it didn't happen sooner. The service is crappy at best and, their customer service is abysmal....
  • katherine zeigler: Today kids have to have internet for everything. I recently received a bill that included over $90 worth of extra charges. It was overages for going o...
  • J. Becker: That's actually not that "costly" if its reliable internet access. My only reasonable option for internet service is (recently very unreliable) Spectr...
  • NJ orlando: Here is the current lawsuit against them it is a class action lawsuit https://topclassactions.com/lawsuit-settlements/consumer-products/internet-speed...
  • NJ orlando: That is because when you bring in a bad modem or router they clean it up do a basic test (maybe) and pack it back up and give it to the next sucker. I...
  • Mary: Well I can understand why, the service here is awful. But they are going to get their money. And when you call ,can't get no one that speaks English c...

Your Account: