Home » Broadband Speed »Community Networks »Consumer News »Public Policy & Gov't »Rural Broadband » Currently Reading:

N.Y. Gov. Andrew Cuomo Vetoes Public Rural Broadband Feasibility Study as the Unserved Struggle On

No service.

Despite New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s $500 million, 2015 Broadband for All initiative which guaranteed broadband service for anyone  that wanted home internet access, five years later rural broadband gaps continue to plague the state.

A bill that would set aside funds to complete a feasibility study to launch a state owned broadband provider of last resort was quietly vetoed by Cuomo at the end of 2019. Assembly member Aileen Gunther (D-Monticello) sponsored the bill after hearing scores of complaints about terrible or non-existent internet access from constituents in her district, which covers the parts of the rural Catskills region north of the Pennsylvania border.

Gunther complained that despite the governor’s broadband initiative, private phone and cable companies were still ignoring rural customers, leaving them with slow DSL service or no internet access at all. Gunther’s bill was a first step in potentially allowing the state to step in and provide service to New Yorkers unable to get broadband from any private provider.

New York has spent over $500 million on its Broadband for All program and made Charter Spectrum an integral part of its broadband expansion plans in return for approval of its 2016 acquisition of Time Warner Cable. But a growing number of the governor’s critics claim the program has failed to deliver on its mandate, stranding thousands of New Yorkers without internet service and tens of thousands more with just one option — unpopular satellite internet access.

Gunther

Gunther was upset to learn that New York was prepared to hand over more than a half billion dollars to large private telecom companies including Frontier Communications and Verizon while not being willing to spend a penny to fund projects to reach New Yorkers for-profit companies could not be dragged kicking and screaming to service.

“We’re all spending millions and millions of dollars on privately owned internet service providers,” said Gunther. “In return for promises, a lot of our communities do not have access to the internet, or if they do have access to the internet, it’s slow and these companies are not, I think, fulfilling the promises made.”

The rural broadband problem is not resolved in the Finger Lakes or Southern Tier regions of New York either. This week, Yates County announced it was joining an effort by Schuyler, Steuben, and Tioga counties, and the Southern Tier Network, to complete a broadband feasibility study to improve internet access in the four counties. Fujitsu Broadband will manage the study and hopes to have results by June. The study will target the pervasive problem of inadequate broadband service in the region, which includes crucial tourist, winery, and agricultural businesses vital to New York’s rural economy.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo announcing rural broadband initiatives in New York in 2015.

Gov. Cuomo has called such initiatives “well-intentioned” but was non committal about contributing more state funds to construct new networks or underwrite further expansion of existing ones. New York is about to begin its annual hard-fought budget negotiations in hopes of completing the state budget by April. Finding funding for such projects will probably require a powerful political advocate able to wrestle funding for further broadband improvements.

Even after spending $500 million, New York’s rural broadband problem has not been resolved. That offers insight into the merits of other state broadband programs, which often limit annual broadband expansion funding to under $30 million annually.

Those still without service are likely in high-cost service areas, where each customer could cost over $20,000 to reach. New York’s Broadband for All program relied on a reverse auction that required private companies to bid to service each unserved address. No wireline provider bid on any high-cost service areas, leaving Hughes Satellite as a subsidized satellite provider of last resort. But inadequate broadband mapping left scores of rural New Yorkers behind without even the option of subsidized satellite internet access.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Berfunkle
Berfunkle
4 months ago

Next week, I’m getting fiber to the home Internet from Ontario and Trumansburg Telephone Companies. $80/month for 500/500 Internet compared to what Spectrum offers, $95/month for 400/20, which is pretty awesome, but even if I wasn’t saving money, I’d go with OTTC just to ensure there’s some kind of competition in my area. I realize I’m lucking out on this since OTTC is a small, regional company that serves mostly towns and rural areas.

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • Nienna: Thank you for mentioning this. I'm newly approved for SSI. As a non-verbal autistic person I socialize on World of Warcraft. When I get my own plac...
  • Pat: As a Spectrum customer with few other options, living in a tiny, but beautiful southern NW US beach town, my resentment is the creepy ways they fin...
  • Donovan May: Count me in...
  • Donovan May: This is theft, there is no other way to describe it....
  • Bette: I put service on seasonal suspension, as I have done for the past 10 years, first with Brighthouse then with Spectrum, when they took over. Suspens...
  • mhorgan65: Or you can get the Moxee Home Phone which also works with Verizon VoLTE service. ...
  • mhorgan65: That model is compatible with Verizon post CDMA, so you should be good to go. :)...
  • mhorgan65: Straight Talk already has a ZTE Home Phone device (Z723EL) that supports VoLTE. If you are still using a Huawei Home Phone device, then you need to...
  • Lee: Frontier's logo should be on urinal screens....
  • Andrew: Good for them. Frontier thanks for holding everyone back all this time. /s...
  • Denis: Any thoughts on when we might get the upgrade in Rochester NY? It seems we’re always the last to get anything from Spectrum.......
  • Marilyn: I cancelled my cable & phone service over the phone and just kept internet with Spectrum on 3/31, the guy tried everything to keep me, putting me ...

Your Account:

131
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x