Home » Editorial & Site News » Currently Reading:

Saturday News & Notes

Phillip Dampier April 25, 2009 Editorial & Site News 12 Comments

birthdayIt’s 81 degrees in Rochester.  Finally decent weather.  One of the New York elected officials we’ve been talking to about the Time Warner usage cap issue somehow found out today is my birthday, and arranged to have a cake dropped off.  You’ll notice the caps stuck on all four sides.  Very funny.  It looks like a Wegmans cake.  Mmmmm….  You don’t know what a real supermarket is until you have a Wegmans in your town.  There is no other supermarket like it.  Period.  The next closest thing, and even that isn’t as good, might be a Whole Foods.  Wegmans is a Rochester-based institution.

Ars Technica is beginning to worry about us. 🙂

A number of Texans are writing in to report their Time Warner Internet service has also been cut off.  We’ve had more than a half dozen so far, and they are still coming in.  The pattern seems to be that if you exceed 40GB in one week, your account may be at risk.

When it is cut off, you have to hope you reach a knowledgeable representative who understands the flag that indicates your cable modem is “in quarantine.”  You then call the Security number, which is almost always answered by voicemail, and then wait for a call back and a lecture on your “excessive use.”  They then turn service back on.

I will be writing a follow-up piece on this problem shortly.  If you can continue to report instances of this, that is helpful.  If you are comfortable, please let me know if I can use your real name, which helps with giving this story added credibility.  It’s getting obvious these are not isolated incidents.  We’ll be seeking broader coverage on this and believe it needs some review by regulatory authorities.

I have received an informal response from someone “in the know” up here in western New York who tells me the home residential visits conducted up in the Rochester area are not unusual and started last fall.  Two people reported they were “prompted” by their complaints about the cap issue to Time Warner, because, as they wrote, the representative brought the issue up.  He’s concerned I’ve jumped to conclusions about why Time Warner does what it does.  Perhaps.  I’ll keep that in mind going forward.  I don’t mind getting the constructive criticism.

An upgrade has been completed to our comments section.  I will need to tinker with some settings, but you will have a window of time to re-edit your comments after posting them in case you find a spelling or grammar error after the fact.  The window will be set to 15 minutes later today.

I am still testing a different theme for StoptheCap! to help people find articles more readily.  You’ll know if/when I elect to use it when the site looks considerably different than it does now.

Inquiries have been arriving about my Frontier DSL service.  It’s complicated.  Very complicated.  It seems the original representative who processed the order completely and totally botched it, leading to layers and layers of confusion.  Follow-up calls to customer service representatives apparently resulted in additional confusion because the entire account was messed up.  Frontier has now assigned an account specialist who is now working with us on getting all of this resolved.  He seems to be doing a good job so far, but the jury is really still out on Frontier at the moment.  We are 10,000 feet out from the central office, and there is a line problem, so our service is currently speed capped to perform at around 256kbps down (and around the same up).  Obviously that’s ridiculous, but they wanted to leave us with something over the weekend.  On Monday, line technicians arrive to work on improving things.

The Rochester Frontier DSL speed for this particular area maxes out at around 6.5Mbps, but they are not currently certain they can do better than 1-2 Mbps in our neighborhood.  I am withholding judgment, because I know line technicians around here can get very creative in resolving issues, so I’ll wait and see what they can do.  But I definitely would not keep the service if 1-2Mbps was as good as it got.

FrontierIt’s an illustration, again, of why DSL is not always a competitive solution in every instance.  The further away you live from the telephone company switching office, the slower the speeds get.  If you are in a rural area, there are lots of places that will never be able to get DSL because of how far away they are from the exchange.  Even in suburban locations, which is where I am, aging equipment and the quality of the copper lines can make or break DSL as a serious competitive contender for a lot of people.

I will be writing up and documenting the entire adventure for a future article.  I am impressed with Frontier assigning an account specialist to work with me on this and ensure my satisfaction to the best of their ability.  That has gone a long way to tempering my frustration over this entire affair.

I am going to enjoy the rest of my birthday.  I still have a ton of video to post here, and I’ve had good response from a lot of you that enjoy the fact we are multimedia-oriented, even if that eats into your “usage allowance.”  I’ve also had response from the media and some politicians.  The former seems to appreciate when I compliment good reporting (and two had a hearty laugh over the catastrophe in journalism on News 14 Carolina — they felt the same way); the latter appreciates they can sit back and watch condensed reports without having to read through all the text I am capable of producing in short periods of time.

And the folks at Ars Technica can relax.  I get out now and again, especially with the improving weather.  A few readers here have recognized me and honked as they realize I’m that power walking guy they’ve seen on Elmwood for the past several years.

Finally, I encountered a hackathon last night when browsing about online seeing who had linked to us.  I have been drafting rebuttals to two articles that link back to us, one coming from an industry insider who isn’t too plussed with our objection to Internet rationing plans, and another that, charitably, seems to be drinking the Kool-Aid, perhaps unintentionally.  We’ll see.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
12 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ausin
Ausin
15 years ago

Happy Birthday!

Mazakman
Mazakman
15 years ago

First off, Happy Birthday Phil ! Yes, today has been one of those chamber of commerce days here in the Rochester area that helps us to forget the winter that is now gone… hopefully. Hope that the Frontier techs and csr’s get your DSL service straightened out and running faster. As I have documented in the past, I have one of those remotes right around the corner from me and I am “riding out” the rest of my one year RR deal before I make a decision to return to Frontier. If I see the speeds that I saw last… Read more »

Dave
Dave
15 years ago

Happy Birthday, Phil! Thanks for all you do.

Smith6612
Smith6612
15 years ago

Happy Birthday Phil! It was nice of that elected official or whoever to give you a cake, thumbs up to them. But at least we know what is going on with the DSL now. If you are 10,000ft in wire from the CO, if Frontier gives you ADSL2+ to run off of (which they should have in Rochester) you should easilly pull 7Mbps+/768kbps given the wire gauge is good (22 aWg like they use in my area) where you are, unless the wiring out where you are is terrible. Good luck though and have a great Birthday! Also it’s 82… Read more »

Stephen
Stephen
15 years ago

Happy Birthday Phil. I am scheduled for my install back to Frontier on May 6th. It was a very pleasant experience and I will write up how I got it moving and how it went. I was a happy Frontier customer last year before talked caps. We will see how it goes now.

jr
jr
15 years ago

Happy birthday! Thanks for your great leadership against TW

KP
KP
15 years ago

How do I find out where the switching office is?

Smith6612
Smith6612
15 years ago
Reply to  KP

If it’s for Frontier or another telephone company, simply ask someone who works for them. The local techs can tell you anything you want to know about the local infrastructure 🙂

Grayson Peddie
Grayson Peddie
15 years ago

Happy Birthday Phil! And thanks for your articles and your leadership against Time Warner. I get freaked out when one of the bills in Wilson, NC prevented municipal broadband from spreading throughout the city. Oh, and congrats to Wilson, NC for stepping up and provide broadband service for their area. I wish Tallahassee can do that, but I’m okay with Comcast. However, if only they could unbundle $10 basic cable service from HSI as I never watch basic cable (only with my antenna connected to my computer’s ATSC TV tuner) while not having to pay $60 for HSI if I’m… Read more »

Sunflower
Sunflower
15 years ago

Happy Birthday!!
And thanks for creating this site to get this info out there. 🙂

Corrine
15 years ago

Belated Happy Birthday, Phil. Rochester certainly rolled out a beautiful day for you.

As to the concern expressed by Ars Technica, without the “obsessive detail” provided here we would most assuredly be facing caps by the fall.

Regardless of what you were told in the informal response from someone “in the know”, the implication in the conversation I had with the Residential Account Specialist was that they were indeed reaching out due to the recent “bad publicity”.

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

Your Account:

Stop the Cap!