Home » AT&T »Consumer News »Public Policy & Gov't »Verizon » Currently Reading:

AT&T Shamed to Drop $1 Million Lawsuit Against Customer Over Fraudulent Calls

Phillip Dampier July 9, 2012 AT&T, Consumer News, Public Policy & Gov't, Verizon 3 Comments

ToddTool could have been forced into bankruptcy, taking its 14 employees straight to the unemployment line, had AT&T followed through on its threat to collect a million dollar fraudulent phone bill.

Michael Smith and his 14 employees can now sleep again after AT&T dropped a $1.15 million lawsuit against Smith’s small manufacturing company after the story went viral.

The lawsuit was filed over fraudulent long distance calls placed through Smith’s PBX phone system to the war-torn nation of Somalia over a four day period in 2009.

Smith discovered the fraud after getting long distance bills totaling $891,470 the following month.

More than $260,000 of additional charges were billed by Verizon, Smith’s landline phone company, and Verizon forgave those charges a few months after Smith filed a billing dispute. Verizon noticed the unusual calling activity and temporarily suspended Smith’s international long distance service. The phone hackers then simply used a “dial-around” long distance access code for AT&T to keep the calls going through, resulting in a huge bill from AT&T, which charged $22 a minute for the calls.

Unlike Verizon, AT&T wanted its money and despite multiple attempts to get credit for the fraudulent long distance calls, AT&T refused to relent, filing suit against Smith for the full cost of the fraudulent calls, plus interest.

Smith told a Salem, Mass. newspaper if he paid the bill, it would force his company into bankruptcy and put his 14 employees on the unemployment line.

The company claims in its lawsuit Smith should have known better — securing his PBX system more effectively against international long distance fraud and that under Federal Communications Commission regulations, AT&T is entitled to collect from the owner of the phone line, regardless of who actually made the call.

Smith told The Salem News he’s tried to resolve the matter, even reaching out to the CEO of AT&T, but a secretary at the company called and said that once AT&T refers a case to outside counsel, they are done talking.

AT&T later offered to waive the accumulating interest charges on the unpaid balance (now $197,000 and growing) if Smith paid the company $891,470 for the phone calls to Somalia.

Smith filed a countersuit instead, claiming AT&T is abusing the legal process and violating Massachusetts consumer protection laws. A judge was pushing the case to mediation.

Smith’s interview with the Salem newspaper came at additional risk: AT&T’s lawyers threatened they would take action if he “disparaged” the company’s name in the media.

After the story ran nationwide this morning on the Associated Press wire service, the company suddenly dropped the case.

In a statement sent to the media, AT&T writes it is no longer pursuing its claims against Michael Smith, of Ipswich, “though we are entitled by law to collect the amounts owed.”

Share

Currently there are 3 comments on this Article:

  1. Judy Kiernan says:

    Our phone system was recently hacked into and we have about $3,000 in fraudulent charges!! We are with Time Warner Cable and they are now telling us they will disconnect our phones. That won’t help our business. I’d switch to avoid this but we have a three year contract – so will have to wait for the disconnect and then switch (I guess). Everyone knows that computers can be hacked into and try to protect against this. We never knew that our phone system could be hacked!!

  2. bart says:

    AT$T charged me for a product I never ordered, wanted or needed!!! And, now they refuse to return the funds that they stole from me!!!
    I think they do this because all the executives starting with Randall L. Stephenson get paid so much money. They have to figure out ways to legitimately steal as much of their salary as possible. These people are no different than the crazies who horde cats or trash, except these people horde money.

    http://www.zazzle.com/greedy_bastard_randall_l_stephenson_t_shirts-235450358072730429







Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • Phillip Dampier: Long time readers here will know, of course, that we chase everyone that is pro-company, anti-consumer, regardless of party....
  • Phillip Dampier: Give me the model/type of the current battery in your system and I'll do some research. Sometimes the low low price elsewhere is for lousy Chinese bat...
  • KM: Anyone know a source for third party batteries for these? Comcast's $35 + shipping seems high, especially if you want 2 which the box allows....
  • elfonblog: Yeah, I'm getting pretty sick of the word "unlimited" meaning "for any amount of time" rather than "for any amount of activity". Of course, people thi...
  • Paul Houle: Wow, here's an example of a cable company doing the right thing....
  • txpatriot: Thanx I missed Hoyle. Everyone else cited in the article was identified by party affiliation except Hoyle and Black. I was just trying to ensure you...
  • Phillip Dampier: That should be evident from the fact the Dems controlled the legislature for a century until 2011. Hoyle and Harrell were also Democrats....
  • txpatriot: Just for the record, former House Speaker Jim Black was (and maybe still is) a Democrat. You can read about the scandal at: http://en.wikipedia.or...
  • txpatriot: Brian, calm down and take a couple of deep breaths. If you have a complaint, it's with ACSI and how they categorized ISPs for purposes of their s...
  • Phillip Dampier: An Internet Service Provider is defined here (and elsewhere, to be honest) as any company using any technology to deliver Internet access to consumers...
  • Brian: Please tell me who the ISPs are ! In another article I read recently the writer said that the ISPs were VZ, AT&T and Comcast. Can't you get ...
  • txpatriot: Pulling the battery would be the best way to ensure the cell network can't track your movements. But that's kinda inconvenient....

Your Account: