We collectively sighed last Wednesday when the Senate Finance Committee temporarily pulled S1209, but the victory is short-lived. Sources tell us S1209 is scheduled to return this Tuesday, one day after the long Memorial Day weekend.
We are not happy with some of the rumors that have been circulating around the Legislative Building in Raleigh. One suggests S1209 will be modified into a one year, renewable moratorium on municipal broadband while a joint task force ponders questions about financing of municipal broadband, broadband adoption and speed, and overall competition in North Carolina. Without a clear sunset provision, the legislature can renew the moratorium indefinitely, assuring incumbent phone and cable companies of a continued easy ride into our wallets.
Much has also been said by Sen. Clodfelter regarding the legality of municipal broadband in North Carolina. Some of his earlier comments suggest he’d be a proponent for a moratorium while the state legislature thrashes out the legal questions.
But the courts have already effectively dealt with this question and handed victory to municipalities. Why bother with a moratorium when in 2005, Laurinburg, North Carolina won its court battle against big telecom companies. The judge ruled:
“Laurinburg’s network is run over fiber optic “wires or cable,” providing a “system” for “transmit[ting]” and “receiv[ing]” electronic signals capable of being converted to “audio” and/or “video” streams of information. See N.C. Gen. Stat. § 160A-319(b). We believe this fits within a broad construction of the definition of a CTS. Therefore, we hold that Laurinburg is acting within its municipal authority to run its network, and was not acting ultra vires in contracting with School Link to provide the network’s ISP service.”
Doesn’t the legislature have better things to do than to spend all of this valuable time doing work for big phone and cable companies?
We need you to again write and call your legislators. We have been told by numerous sources that your input has been very effective in pushing back S1209. The more North Carolina consumers speak out against this anti-consumer bill, the less likely it will ever become law.
Here are the points you need to raise in your next letter or phone call:
- Why is the legislature still spending time on this unnecessary, anti-consumer legislation? S1209 is wanted by large phone and cable companies. You want your town or city to have every option open to deliver better service if a consensus is reached for it in your community. The current system already provides effective checks and balances. We don’t need S1209.
- Studying broadband issues is fine, but placing a moratorium on municipal broadband projects in the meantime is completely unacceptable.
- Corning’s plant in Hickory, North Carolina produces 40 percent of the world’s supply of fiber optic cable. Passing S1209 impedes fiber projects in North Carolina, hurting our own workers and state economy.
- North Carolina needs all the broadband expansion it can get. We are ranked 41st out of 50 states. Passing S1209 preserves mediocre broadband service in our state indefinitely.
For some of you, this will be your third or fourth call or e-mail. Perhaps it’s time to remind legislators you are becoming increasingly concerned that measures like S1209 continue to be debated. While Time Warner Cable and CenturyLink/Embarq’s legislative priorities continue to get plenty of time and attention in Raleigh, they don’t get a vote in the next election. Remind them you do, and your continued support hinges on whether you can feel confident members represents your interests, not those of big cable and phone companies.
Remember the three rules when contacting your legislators:
- Be polite.
- Be persuasive.
- Be persistent.
Well-informed constituents who can defeat industry talking points represents the nuclear option against bad telecommunications legislation.
Now get on the phones and e-mail and get busy. Remember — one e-mail message per address. No carbon copies!
Here is the list:
| County | First Name | Last Name | Tel (919) | Party | Email Address | Leg Asst email |
| Alamance | Anthony E. | Foriest | 301-1446 | Dem | Tony.Foriest@ncleg.net | Foriestla@ncleg.net |
| Buncombe | Martin L. | Nesbitt | 715-3001 | Dem | Martin.Nesbitt@ncleg.net | Nesbittla@ncleg.net |
| Cabarrus | Fletcher L. | Hartsell | 733-7223 | Rep | Fletcher.Hartsell@ncleg.net | Hartsellla@ncleg.net |
| Carteret | Jean R. | Preston | 733-5706 | Rep | Jean.Preston@ncleg.net | Prestonla@ncleg.net |
| Catawba | Austin M. | Allran | 733-5876 | Rep | Austin.Allran@ncleg.net | Allranla@ncleg.net |
| Chatham | Robert | Atwater | 715-3036 | Dem | Bob.Atwater@ncleg.net | Atwaterla@ncleg.net |
| Cherokee | John J. | Snow | 733-5875 | Dem | John.Snow@ncleg.net | Snowla@ncleg.net |
| Columbus | R. C. | Soles | 733-5963 | Dem | RC.Soles@ncleg.net | Solesla@ncleg.net |
| Cumberland | Margaret H. | Dickson | 733-5776 | Dem | Margaret.Dickson@ncleg.net | Dicksonla@ncleg.net |
| Cumberland | Larry | Shaw | 733-9349 | Dem | Larry.Shaw@ncleg.net | Shawla@ncleg.net |
| Davie | Andrew C. | Brock | 715-0690 | Rep | Andrew.Brock@ncleg.net | Brockla@ncleg.net |
| Duplin | Charles W. | Albertson | 733-5705 | Dem | Charlie.Albertson@ncleg.net | Albertsonla@ncleg.net |
| Durham | Floyd B. | McKissick | 733-4599 | Dem | Floyd.McKissick@ncleg.net | McKissickla@ncleg.net |
| Edgecombe | S. Clark | Jenkins | 715-3040 | Dem | Clark.Jenkins@ncleg.net | Jenkinsla@ncleg.net |
| Forsyth | Linda | Garrou | 733-5620 | Dem | Linda.Garrou@ncleg.net | Garroula@ncleg.net |
| Gaston | David W. | Hoyle | 733-5734 | Dem | David.Hoyle@ncleg.net | Hoylela@ncleg.net |
| Haywood | Joe Sam | Queen | 733-3460 | Dem | Joesam.Queen@ncleg.net | Queenla@ncleg.net |
| Henderson | Tom M. | Apodaca | 733-5745 | Rep | Tom.Apodaca@ncleg.net | Apodacala@ncleg.net |
| Johnston | David | Rouzer | 733-5748 | Rep | David.Rouzer@ncleg.net | Rouzerla@ncleg.net |
| Mecklenburg | Daniel G. | Clodfelter | 715-8331 | Dem | Daniel.Clodfelter@ncleg.net | Clodfelterla@ncleg.net |
| Mecklenburg | Charlie Smith | Dannelly | 733-5955 | Dem | Charlie.Dannelly@ncleg.net | Dannelly@ncleg.net |
| Mecklenburg | Bob | Rucho | 733-5655 | Rep | Bob.Rucho@ncleg.net | Ruchola@ncleg.net |
| Moore | Harris | Blake | 733-4809 | Rep | Harris.Blake@ncleg.net | Blakela@ncleg.net |
| Nash | A. B. | Swindell | 715-3030 | Dem | AB.Swindell@ncleg.net | Swindellla@ncleg.net |
| New Hanover | Julia | Boseman | 715-2525 | Dem | Julia.Boseman@ncleg.net | Bosemanla@ncleg.net |
| Onslow | Harry | Brown | 715-3034 | Rep | Harry.Brown@ncleg.net | Brownla@ncleg.net |
| Orange | Eleanor | Kinnaird | 733-5804 | Dem | Ellie.Kinnaird@ncleg.net | Kinnairdla@ncleg.net |
| Randolph | Jerry W. | Tillman | 733-5870 | Rep | Jerry.Tillman@ncleg.net | Tillmanla@ncleg.net |
| Robeson | Michael P. | Walters | 733-5651 | Dem | Michael.Walters@ncleg.net | Waltersla@ncleg.net |
| Rockingham | Philip Edward | Berger | 733-5708 | Rep | Phil.Berger@ncleg.net | Bergerla@ncleg.net |
| Scotland | William R. | Purcell | 733-5953 | Dem | William.Purcell@ncleg.net | Purcellla@ncleg.net |
| Surry | Don W. | East | 733-5743 | Rep | Don.East@ncleg.net | Eastla@ncleg.net |
| Union | W. Edward | Goodall | 733-7659 | Rep | Eddie.Goodall@ncleg.net | Goodallla@ncleg.net |
| Wake | Daniel T. | Blue | 733-5752 | Dem | Dan.Blue@ncleg.net | Bluela@ncleg.net |
| Wake | Neal | Hunt | 733-5850 | Rep | Neal.Hunt@ncleg.net | Huntla@ncleg.net |
| Wake | Joshua H. | Stein | 715-6400 | Dem | Josh.Stein@ncleg.net | Steinla@ncleg.net |
| Wake | Richard Y. | Stevens | 733-5653 | Rep | Richard.Stevens@ncleg.net | Stevensla@ncleg.net |
| Watauga | Steve | Goss | 733-5742 | Dem | Steve.Goss@ncleg.net | Gossla@ncleg.net |
Other stories of interest:
- Action Alert: North Carolina, Get Writing Now for Municipal Broadband Protection!
- Action Alert: Stop Sen. Hoyle’s Anti-Municipal Broadband Bill in North Carolina
- Action Alert: North Carolina Anti-Municipal Broadband Bill Moved to House Utility Committee
- North Carolina Action Alert: Municipal Broadband Moratorium Bill Expected to Be Introduced Wednesday
- Stop the Cap North Carolina Coordinator Reflects on Victory Today

Subscribe
[...] old backscratching-payback-whathaveyou in the NC Senate. Stop the Cap is on this and has some very good questions to bring up with your elected representatives: We need [...]
[...] you can’t go, please consider following through on our Call to Action and get in contact with your legislators and tell them to oppose [...]
[...] doing a little research on municipal broadband, I came across this Stop the Cap post from Greensboro’s own Jay Ovitorre, who calls the earlier version of Senate bill 1209 [...]