Subscribe
A lobbying campaign to add language to a Senate bill that would retroactively apply a federal ban on a tax loophole could derail plans by Verizon to sell off landlines in 14 states to Frontier Communications.
Verizon has relied on provisions of the “Reverse Morris Trust” (RMT) — which lets companies spin-off subsidiaries that merge into smaller companies do so tax free — to dump landlines across the United States, leading to crushing debt and bankruptcy for the buyers.
The House Small Business and Infrastructure Jobs Tax Act of 2010 includes provisions killing off the tax loophole, and the measure passed the House at the end of March by a vote of 246 to 178. But the House measure only applies to new deals, not to those already on the table.
Union officials and several public interest groups are asking consumers to contact their senators and request insertion of language in the Senate companion bill that would apply the ban retroactively to the latest Verizon deal with Frontier Communications.
Such a ban would prevent Verizon and Frontier from walking away from a $600 million dollar tax obligation.
Ironically, one of the House leaders strongly supporting the loophole-closing legislation is Rep. Louise Slaughter (D-NY), whose district covers Frontier’s largest service area — Rochester, New York.
“This tax avoidance loophole does nothing to help people in rural communities who rely on traditional landlines for their phone service,” Slaughter said. “If these transactions are allowed to go forward, Verizon may drop landlines in 14 different states, a development that would mean a loss of jobs for workers and poor quality phone service for millions of Americans.”
For Rep. Peter Welch (D-VT), passage of the ban represents some late justice for the disastrous tax-free deal between Verizon and FairPoint Communications, which took over phone service in his state and other parts of northern New England. FairPoint staggered under the debt load from the deal before collapsing in bankruptcy.
Slaughter
“The RMT was used by Verizon to avoid federal taxes when it sold its northern New England landline operations to FairPoint Communications in 2008,” Welch’s office noted.
“This loophole is bad for taxpayers, bad for consumers and bad for workers. By closing it and investing the savings in job creation, hardworking Americans – not corporations – will benefit,” Welch said.
The ban has special importance for West Virginia, which faces the prospect of turning over most of the state’s phone business to Frontier.
“The House has recognized the Reverse Morris Trust as a greedy grab by corporations to avoid paying their fare share of taxes,” said Elaine Harris, spokeswoman for the Communications Workers of America. “We pay our taxes. Why shouldn’t Verizon have to pay one cent on an $8 billion deal?”
“The Reverse Morris Trust was designed by Wall Street for Wall Street, not West Virginians,” said Ron Collins, a union vice president. “We’re happy Congress shares our view that the Reverse Morris Trust is a tax break for corporations, not a job-creating tool. Without this tax loophole, I don’t believe Verizon would be so eager to sell to Frontier.”
The Charleston Gazette attempted to get the views of Verizon and Frontier over the bill’s passage in the House. Verizon spokeswoman Christy Reap declined comment. A Frontier spokesman couldn’t be reached for comment.
Other stories of interest:
- Verizon Customers Sold Out At Taxpayer Expense: The ‘Reverse Morris Trust’ True Halloween Story
- Opposition Mounts to Verizon-Frontier Deal: Employee Unions Express Concern Consumers Will Get a Raw Deal
- Approve Verizon-Frontier Deal Because Frontier Can’t Do Any Worse for West Virginia?
- CWA Rallies to Fight Verizon-Frontier Deal in West Virginia: Deal Benefits Wall Street Bankers, Not Consumers
- Frontier Gets Approval of Verizon Deal in California, South Carolina, and Nevada; Attacks Union Opposition in West Virginia
[...] those trying to reign in the monpolies aren’t resting either. The House recently passed a law aimed at preventing copper monopolies from unloading massive amounts of debt as they sell off [...]