Home » AT&T »Claro Puerto Rico »Consumer News »Public Policy & Gov't »Sprint »T-Mobile »Wireless Broadband » Currently Reading:

Puerto Ricans Giving Up on U.S. Cell Phone Providers; Mexico’s Claro Has Best Coverage

U.S. cell phone providers are facing increasing criticism they are dragging their feet on restoring cell service in Puerto Rico while Mexican-owned Claro has now successfully restored service in 28 of the territory’s 78 municipalities.

Claro Puerto Rico, owned by Mexican billionaire Carlos Slim’s America Movil, has dramatically outpaced AT&T, T-Mobile, and Sprint in getting their damaged cell phone facilities back up and running. Claro is Puerto Rico’s second most popular cell company behind AT&T.

“Claro is the only one with service here,” Francisco Portales, 47, a customer of privately held Puerto Rico-based network provider Open Mobile told a Reuters reporter while waiting outside the Claro store in Fajardo hoping to buy a phone.

Looking for a signal.

The FCC’s latest update on Tuesday reported about 88% of Puerto Rico is still without cell service, but the agency does not break down network repairs by carrier, and American providers have declared their specific restoration plans to be confidential.

While AT&T complained the lack of commercial power remained its biggest problem, Claro said it had pre-positioned generators, diesel fuel, battery backups, and vehicles 72 hours before the hurricane hit, which appears to have made all the difference in restoring service.

Sprint said late last week its towers were still standing and “largely intact” although it gave no specific information on when service might be restored. T-Mobile was more frank, reporting “it’s going to be a long road to recovery.”

Claro is not taking advantage of its position as the island’s most reliable post-hurricane carrier, allowing customers of other providers to roam on its network where a signal is available. That may be all the good publicity Claro needs to win over new customers after the hurricane damage is repaired.

Claro’s repair trucks.

Mercedes Saldana, a 54-year-old school cafeteria worker and Sprint customer is just one of many now searching shops for a Claro prepaid phone.

“I don’t have any service, none,” she said. “We don’t know when Sprint’s going to be connected again.”

Customers unwilling to switch carriers and won’t roam may have long travel times ahead of them to find a signal. Luis Pacheco, 64, was planning to drive with his wife to Canovanas — 30 to 40 minutes west — in hopes of finding a cell signal to text his daughter in California. That is the nearest community where AT&T has a signal at the moment.

Before the storm, AT&T dominated Puerto Rico with a 34% market share, followed by Claro Puerto Rico with a 26% share. T-Mobile was third with 19%, Open Mobile has 11% and Sprint 10%. Verizon Wireless has no network facilities in Puerto Rico, but travelers with Verizon phones are granted roaming access on Claro’s network.

Currently there are 5 comments on this Article:

  1. LG says:

    I had never heard of this company, being a white man from Boston, but I would like to see companies like this come into the U.S. and take over. So long as they can beat the prices of AT&T, Verizon and Sprint (which should be pretty darn easy), then they could stir up the market.

    I now live in Naples Fl., which Irma’s eye passed over at a Cat 4 hurricane just 3 weeks ago. In the 2 weeks following this, there were practically no cell towers in use. I have a Trac phone that I only use for emergencies, but in this emergency, it was nearly useless. At 4-5am, I could get a very weak data signal and maybe get a text message out, but it was difficult or impossible. Someone I live with had a Verizon phone that didn’t work at all. I would love to see a foreign carrier with lower prices dislodge these big-greed companies. Give me one hungry foreign company for any 10 fat, lazy and greedy American companies any day.

    • kaniki says:

      That is not actually correct.. If you actually check them out, the companies that own sprint is owned by softbank.. which is Japanese.. and Tmobile is owned by 67% by Deutsche Telekom, which in turn is a sub-company of softbank.. So, both are mostly owned by companies out of Japan.. AT&t and Verizon are the only two that are American..

      While I will agree that they could probably do more to get things going, you have to consider that as of 6 days ago, ” 90.3 percent of the island’s 2,671 cellular sites were not functioning.”.. Which means that, considering Verizon has NO cell towers down there (Verizon customers run off of Claro towers), that it means that Claro does not have many towers down there.. Being one of 4 carriers, it they had as much stake in towers as the rest of them, that number would be at least 25% working if he did..

      Plus, the main carriers are probably still dealing with the aftermath of the damage in Florida, which Claro does not have to deal with.. That would leave the main carriers even more short handed..

      Add in “Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority reported that nearly 100 percent of its customers were still without power”.. It makes it much harder to get things working, when there is no power.. and you can not run cell towers off of generators indefinitely.. I bet that once the electric company starts getting power on, things will start coming up much faster..

      • Ian L says:

        Correction to the correction: Deutsche Telekom isn’t owned by Softbank.

        Claro does appear to be a legitimately solid mobile carrier though, and not just in PR. Family used their Nicaragua branch when in that country on a mission trip. H+ rather than LTE where they were, but that could’ve just as easily been due to phone limitations rather than anything on the network.

        I also find it interesting that Claro (CDMA, I assume, since Verizon roams on it) wasn’t getting picked up by Sprint roamers. That said, Sprint would need to push a new PRL to allow roaming on Claro if they didn’t have it before, and you can’t push a PRL from your own network when your own network is down.

        • kaniki says:

          I found these comments.. “AT&T, T-Mobile, Claro, Sprint and Open Mobile are the main mobile service providers in Puerto Rico” “Verizon Wireless stores and towers are not in Puerto Rico, after having sold their towers to Claro in 2007.” “please keep in mind that Puerto Rico is part of the Extended Network, which means Verizon has agreements with other cell carriers in the area to allow Verizon customers to use for service.”

          I just looked up some new info, and it seems that part of the problem with the towers being down, is because of theft.. “Its crews are trying to get generators to cell sites though it said that stolen generators and fuel have made security a concern.” “After an effort was made to get the diesel, the drivers to transport it and the security measures to break through and carry fuel to the towers, they are stealing it and cutting the fiber.” There is also comments about theft of copper, among other things too.. They are denying that, but, if you are stealing generators, fuel, cutting fiber, etc.. You can not tell me no one is stealing copper too.

          “PREPA, the electric company on the island, has a massive $9 billion debt, as Vox’s Alexia Fernández Campbell has explained, and in July it defaulted on an interest payment.”

          I guess that explains why their electric grid is in such bad shape…

          You are right.. I found an article that said

          “Japan’s Softbank, which owns Sprint, and Deutsche Telekom, which owns 67 percent of T-Mobile, still have to negotiate on the details, including financing and the termination fee to be paid should the merger get blocked by regulators, the source familiar with the matter said.”

          I was probably in the middle of reading that sentence and the phone rang or something, and I missed the last half, leaving the first part.. “Japan’s Softbank, which owns Sprint, and Deutsche Telekom, which owns 67 percent of T-Mobile, “, which is where I got that.. It kind of did not make sense because I thought that it was a German company.. which it is..

  2. Ian L says:

    Just did a bit of research and apparently Claro switched their network to GSM/UMTS/LTE awhile back, away from CDMA, so roaming on Verizon stopped at that point. Verizon now roams on Open Mobile, which looks like it’ll merge with Sprint in areas that it serves at some point. Guess that explains why Sprint can’t roam on Claro. Surprised that neither AT&T nor T-Mobile have set up roaming with Claro while they get their own networks up…no wait, I’m not, because that would probably cost those carriers a boatload in roaming fees.







Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • Kenny Gregory: I will be glad when the American people wake up to see how the government is only interested in money and power and care less and less each day about ...
  • A: I got notice for price hike from Nov 2017, this is 3rd time price hike since 2015...
  • Roger: Better get your tin foil hat tuned up, Dave. The idea behind the ACA was a noble one. The idea of mandatory health insurance was to build the pool o...
  • Limboaz: What!? No mention of anti-trust hawk Paul Weiss being nominated to head the FTC? He needs to break up the tech behemoths, like Comcrap, Slime Warner, ...
  • Dave: How long before democrats force households to buy cable so they can get “real news”? If they could force us to buy health insurance, then why would th...
  • JayS: Will these price hikes attract over-builders, like Google, to fire-up the trenching machine again? Insight the likes of AT&T, Verizon, T-mobile, S...
  • George: It's a good thing Charter was allowed to buy up Time Warner, or else we'd still have $15/mo cable internet service packages available... If you're no...
  • EJ: Trump and Pia are a blessing in disguise you will see. As long as someone somewhere can muster a decent Bernie type person we only have three more yea...
  • Dale: In our area suddenlink just downgraded the 200mbps from unlimited data to a 350gb data cap. I don't know if this is only for new customers or existing...
  • Larry Gall: This has become far, far too important a resource for the likes of these jerks to control (in it's entirety). The jerks I'm referring to are the Holl...
  • Matt: Until an operator has the guts to give true à la carte options to the customer the trend is just going to continue. Everyone I know who has cut the c...
  • EJ: They better do it while the getting is good. Raise your price and be put on the radar for unfair rate increases. Attempt to sell that you NEED to incr...

Your Account:

%d bloggers like this: