Home » Broadband Speed »Competition »Consumer News »Data Caps »Frontier »Rural Broadband » Currently Reading:

Frontier Losing 8.5% of Customers Every Year; Products Like ‘Second Connect’ Explain Why

Phillip Dampier November 8, 2011 Broadband Speed, Competition, Consumer News, Data Caps, Frontier, Rural Broadband 5 Comments

Frontier Communications continues to lose access line customers at a rate of 8.5 percent overall, 9.8 percent in the former Verizon service areas they acquired more than a year ago.  The company’s third quarter results show lackluster performance as revenue declines of 30 percent impacted both their residential and business customer units.

Company officials spent most of the question and answer session responding to Wall Street concerns about revenue, spending, promotions, customer churn, the company’s pension fund, and the outright defection of Frontier FiOS TV customers away from the fiber network the phone company inherited from Verizon.

Mike McCormack of Nomura Securities suggest the weak figures should concern investors because it may show Frontier unable to compete effectively with cable companies, which also offer phone service.

Frontier CEO Maggie Wilderotter put her best face forward trying to promote the company’s successes, particularly bringing DSL broadband to former Verizon service areas:

“Our broadband expansion reached an additional 126,000 new homes in the acquired properties during the quarter, bringing our year-to-date total to 352,000 which is on track to reach our 2011 goal of increasing broadband availability to more than 400,000 additional homes. Broadband availability in the acquired properties is now 80%, a significant increase from the mid-60% range when we acquired them. As a result of our expansion and sales efforts, we had a very strong quarter for broadband growth, adding 16,900 total DSL subscribers, a 38% sequential increase from Q2. We also added 2,300 wireless data customers. This growth reflected the effectiveness of our local engagement model, as well as organic demand for broadband in both legacy and acquired properties.

“We have also largely completed our efforts to migrate middle mile congestion, which now gives us the ability to more effectively market higher speeds in markets that were already enabled.”

Frontier executives sought to portray West Virginia as their biggest success story.

Daniel J. McCarthy, Frontier’s chief operating officer and executive vice-president, claims Frontier’s installation of 12 integrated fiber rings throughout the state provides broadband capacity and integrated network capability beyond what is available anywhere else in the United States from a state-wide perspective.  McCarthy claims Frontier is on track to turn West Virginia from one of the least connected states in the nation to one of the most connected.

But Margaret Kings from MacArthur, W.V. says she’ll believe it when she sees it, and she hasn’t seen it yet.

“My extended family has experienced endless problems dealing with Frontier in this state, and I have relatives in the Panhandle to boot,” Kings says. “We have collectively won more than $300 in service credits for out of service broadband and phone service, slow speeds when it rains, and missed appointments, billing errors, sneaky charges, and contract disputes.”

Kings’ immediate family left Frontier for Suddenlink more than a year ago when she moved.

“Why pay Frontier more for phone service and 1.7Mbps broadband when I can pay Suddenlink less for their phone service and 10Mbps Internet access,” she asks.

Frontier hopes to win back former customers with new broadband services, such as their newly-introduced “Second Connect” service, which delivers a second DSL line for existing broadband homes for what the company claims is $14.99 a month.  Frontier says a few thousand customers have signed up for the service, which is now being pitched aggressively by Frontier’s call centers.

But some customers who have signed up for the service are accusing Frontier of billing fraud for wildly misleading customers about the true cost of the service.

The $14.99 price tag Frontier advertises omits modem rental fees, taxes, surcharges, and other fees customers first discover on their monthly bill.

Chris Photoni discovered, after five calls and a combined two hours on hold, the true out-the-door price for Frontier Second Connect is actually $48 for him.  The Broadband Reports reader elaborates:

Don’t waste your time. Even after the ‘corrections’ the Second Connect line cost around $48. I say ‘around,’ [because] I haven’t met a staff member yet that could correctly calculate tax. How convenient for you Frontier. Their computer system can calculate it for your bill, but is unable to calculate it when inquiring about the service.

The new ‘taxes’ come to $27.64!

Frontier is one of the worst phone companies. They have terrible customer service, and the wait times usually seem to be 20-30 minutes per call. Most issues take at least THREE calls to resolve. I’ve actually have been on hold for 25 minutes as I’m writing this.

Kings said she wouldn’t have bothered inquiring about Second Connect in the first place.

“Let me understand this,” she writes. “The same phone company that offers 1.7Mbps to my house wants another $15 a month to ‘double my speed?’  I could pay $100 a month to Frontier for 3Mbps broadband along with my phone line or pay Suddenlink $100 for 10Mbps broadband, phone and cable-TV service.”

Other highlights from the conference call:

  • Frontier is getting into the home security business in a two state trial with ADT and Protection 1.  Customers will be strongly encouraged to bundle the home security service with other telecommunications products to hold them in contracts and provide discounts up to 15 percent;
  • Frontier will begin to resell AT&T wireless voice and data services in bundles with existing products. Frontier plans to trial this service during the first half of 2012 before expanding it nationally.  This service is only going to be available to bundled service customers.  Why customers wouldn’t pursue an agreement with AT&T themselves, without the phone company’s involvement, isn’t well-explained;
  • The company plans no significant high-value promotional offers for the 4th quarter.  They didn’t pitch any during the 3rd quarter either.  Customers with pre-existing promotions, including “free satellite TV for 2011” or “six months of free DSL” will find their bills rising considerably as those promotions expire in the next few months;
  • Frontier’s pension plan is not in the best shape.  The company had to contribute $58 million of real estate to the plan fund to manage investment losses for the year;
  • Frontier’s $500 FiOS installation fee has effectively kept new customers away from the fiber network.  Although the company claims it wants to maintain support for FiOS, video customers have left in droves and a smaller number of broadband customers have left as well, primarily for Comcast;
  • Frontier plans to continue investment in its middle mile network to handle broadband traffic growth in 2012 and 2013.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andrew
Andrew
12 years ago

Wow. I’d love to know how the CEO and COO got promoted to their current position.

How embarrassing for them. I’m sure their golden parachute is set to go though… they’ll fleece the company for all they can when it finally fails.

Bob
Bob
12 years ago

Frontier is a shaddy company and I hope they continue to lose customers. I have had so many problems with them. They are dishonest and I everytime I call I hear a different story of why the billing is wrong or what their current DSL pricing is. I literally called at least 3 or 4 different times and got different answers as to what my DSL pricing would be.

DO NOT sign up with Frontier…avoid them at all costs!

Carol
Carol
12 years ago

We recently switched from Frontier phone/internet (DSL) to Mediacom. Mediacom was running promotions in our area (south central IL) that were half the cost of our Frontier service. When I received the final bill from Frontier, there were two $200.00 “early termination” fees charged!. Turns out, back in December, ’08, Frontier put our local and long-distance service “on contract” to qualify us for “cheaper rates”, without telling us. I’d not heard of putting local service on contract before, and when you check Frontier’s “Terms and conditions” on-line, customers are not told this. You can find it only by checking “frontier.com/etf”.… Read more »

Jack Spratt
Jack Spratt
12 years ago

Frontier Communcation antics are reminiscent of Marx Brothers.

James
James
12 years ago

I am absolutely disgusted with Frontier. I had Fios internet service from Verizon and it generally has been very reliable. Last summer I started running into all sorts of connectivity problems despite customer service insisting that everything was fine and then finally with the help of some forum members we tracked it down to an improperly configured router on Frontier’s side. Then in DecemberI got a notice that my bill was delinquent despite having been set to auto pay for quite some time. I called and the representative insisted that I was good to go. Well the next month I… Read more »

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

Your Account:

Stop the Cap!