Home » Broadband Speed »Competition »Consumer News »Frontier »Time Warner Cable »Verizon » Currently Reading:

Upstate New York Broadband Rankings Out: Rochester Ranks Last in Speed and Value

Phillip Dampier April 6, 2011 Broadband Speed, Competition, Consumer News, Frontier, Time Warner Cable, Verizon No Comments

In an upstate New York match-up, the Rochester/Finger Lakes region scored dead last in broadband speed and value, according to data from Broadband.com.

Why are broadband speeds so much lower in the Flower City?  Blame Frontier Communications, which continues to pitch its decade-old DSL product, delivering an average speed of 4.45Mbps, while other upstate cities enjoy access and competition from Verizon’s fiber to the home network FiOS.  Frontier DSL actually often costs more, after taxes and fees, than Time Warner Cable’s much-faster cable broadband product, Road Runner, which rates an average download speed of 12.77Mbps in Rochester.  Frontier does manage to pull one win — higher upload speed DSL providers can often achieve in cities where cable operators keep upstream speeds as low as possible.

Time Warner Cable has dragged its feet upgrading broadband service in the area to its DOCSIS 3 platform other upstate cities have had since last year.  DOCSIS 3 should arrive within the next 4-8 weeks, which should boost broadband speeds, but may not deliver lower broadband prices because of Frontier’s uncompetitiveness in the area.

 

(Source: Broadband.com)

The top city in upstate New York for download speed is the state capital, Albany.  But Buffalo wins the contest for upload speed thanks to aggressive competition for Time Warner from Verizon in the Queen City.  Buffalo also pays the least for service — nearly $5 less per month than residents in Rochester pay on average.  Syracuse scores in the middle — but closer in terms of speed and value to other Verizon-served cities.

Slow and expensive broadband service can hamper economic development and costs consumers more.  Unfortunately, there are no signs Frontier Communications has plans to do anything differently in its largest service area — a classic driver of the accelerating number of customers calling to pull the plug on their landline service.

Time Warner Cable's Road Runner vs. Frontier Communications' DSL (Speeds are downstream/upstream; Source: Broadband.com)

Share






Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • wayne dalton garage door opener manual: Today, I went to the beachfront with my children. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said "You can hear the ocean if you ...
  • genie intellicode garage door opener: When I originally commented I clicked the "Notify me when new comments are added" checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four e-mails w...
  • anon: it is only expected when you are operating in an urban ghetto like philadelphia....
  • Joe Siegler: The Time Warner Cable office near me has the same kind of set up....
  • Scott: Sad thing is that service center actually looks half decent, the facility I went to on the way out of town as I left Chicago and was cancelling my cab...
  • Glenda: I have been having trouble with winstream also it has been being slow and this is the only source of internet where I live so I wish the would fix thi...
  • Todd: I was just offered 18Mbps for $33 24Mbps for $35 45Mbps for $40 I've never anything faster than 12 in my life so I went for 45. But then I wa...
  • Phillip Dampier: We tweeted him early this afternoon before the article is published. He can rebut it here if he likes....
  • Bryan Cummings: Phil, Have you reached out to gentlemen you feature in this story to see if he will provide a response letter providing his side of the story ? ...
  • Elizabeth: You can also post comments online--I just did, using your letter! (It's a little over the character limit, though.) http://documents.dps.ny.gov/pu...
  • Will Knot Tell: I changed to Verizon before moving to Alaska. I called and spoke to the rep and got online and chatted so I could save the conversation because I have...
  • Will Knot Tell: I have been waiting for ACS Internet services (4G cell and Broadband) in Delta Junction for 19 months. I live 4 miles from Delta Junction and apparent...

Your Account: