Subscribe
Windstream Corporation has agreed to acquire Newton, Iowa-based Iowa Telecom for $530 million in stock and cash, making it the fourth acquisition for the rural-focused Windstream in 2009. It will also take on $600 million of Iowa Telecom’s debt as part of the transaction, which caused Standard & Poors to reduce Windstream’s credit rating to junk status – BB.
Like Frontier Communications, Windstream is engaged in aggressive expansion to stake out its position serving rural America. The company has spent $1.3 billion on acquisitions in just the last six months, trying to keep up with other large independent providers like Frontier and CenturyLink.
“Our whole investment thesis was to grow scale in rural America,” Windstream Chief Executive Jeff Gardner told the Wall Street Journal. “I still think there’s a great deal of consolidation left with smaller players, where the pressure is the most obvious.”
Windstream, based in Little Rock, Arkansas, serves customers in 16 states, mostly in the midwest and south. Iowa Telecom serves former GTE service areas in Iowa and Minnesota.
For employees in Newton, east of Des Moines, the purchase brings fear of significant job reductions. Iowa Telecom has 800 employees, and comments by Windstream’s Gardner suggest downsizing is forthcoming. Windstream expects $35 million in cost savings annually, and some of that will be achieved by dispensing with unneeded Iowa Telecom workers post-merger. Windstream has only promised to maintain a call center in Iowa.
http://www.phillipdampier.com/video/WHO Des Moines Iowa Telecom Bought 11-25-09.flvWHO-TV Des Moines reported Windstream’s buyout of Iowa Telecom was like “lightning striking twice” for Newton residents, leaving an economically-challenged community in fear. (11/25/09 – 2 minutes)
Iowa Telecom provides customers with a familiar bundle of services common among independent phone companies. As well as providing traditional wired phone lines, Iowa Telecom markets Xstream DSL at speeds up to 15Mbps in some areas, and resells DISH Network satellite service for customers looking for a video option.
Lexcom's DSL price chart shows budget-busting prices for relatively slow DSL service
Windstream provides DSL service up to 12Mbps in some areas.
Before Iowa Telecom, Windstream’s earlier acquisitions included:
- D&E Communications of Pennsylvania — Windstream fetched the independent provider in a stock and cash transaction that added about 150,000 additional telephone lines to Windstream’s portfolio in Pennsylvania.
- Lexcom — Windstream picked up this Davidson County, North Carolina independent for $141 million. Lexcom needs serious technology upgrades to improve service.
- NuVox — A Greenville, South Carolina-based business services provider.
Windstream has hinted they’re not done with acquisitions yet, fueling some speculation their next targets may be Consolidated Communications, which provides service in Illinois, Pennsylvania, and Texas or Alaska Communications Systems, another business service provider.
http://www.phillipdampier.com/video/KCCI Des Moines Will $1.1B Iowa Telecom Sale Mean Job Losses 11-24-09.flvKCCI-TV Des Moines reported residents of Newton were “shocked” and “disturbed” about the Iowa Telecom buyout, because of potentially staggering layoffs to come after Windstream closes the deal. (11/24/09 – 2 minutes)
Not everyone is singing the blues about Windstream’s buyout of Iowa Telecom. Despite the transaction’s impact on Windstream’s credit rating, Wall Street has supported Windstream with a strong stock price, owing to the company’s relentless desire to deliver dividends to stockholders.
http://www.phillipdampier.com/video/CNBC Cramer on Windstream 12-7-09 1025.flv
CNBC’s Jim Cramer loves the “massive dividends” Windstream provides to stockholders. But Cramer also issues some caveats, reminding viewers of FairPoint Communications, another former high-dividend stock… until it went bankrupt. Cramer interviews Windstream CEO Jeff Gardner about the company and the future of independent phone companies in general. (12/7/09 – 10 minutes)
http://www.phillipdampier.com/video/CNBC Windstream Profile NASDAQ 12-10-2009 222.flv
CNBC reports on Windstream’s move to the NASDAQ and interviews CEO Jeff Gardner about the future for the telecom industry in general. (12/10/09 – 2 minutes)
Other stories of interest:
- AT&T Tells Employees to Parrot Company Talking Points In Anti-Net Neutrality Comments (But Use Your Personal E-Mail)
- Mediacom vs. Sinclair: Consumers Stuck In The Middle As Companies Fight For Your Money
- Burlington Telecom Needs to Create New Innovative Services Comcast Doesn’t Provide, Telecom Consultant Says
- Telecom New Zealand Fined For Misleading Customers With “Unlimited” Broadband Offer That Heavily Throttled Speeds
- Frontier Reveals Plans of Usage Cap Implementation to Employees; Leaves Customers In The Dark Until It’s A Done Deal
I’ll play Devil’s Advocate here, as usual.
What are Iowa Telecom’s rates and services like for the majority of its customers? Now, compare those to Windstream’s rates for the same things. Yes, you’re going to lose the ability to do 15/1 ADSL2+ until Windstream decides to add that tier, but in return you’ll get internet packages with 768 kbps up no matter what tier you choose, and prices ranging from $35 to $45 per month standalone. The price drops by another $5 per month if you add in voice service, and Windstream is pretty darned aggressive with their voice plus DSL bundles, though they aren’t touching TV with a ten foot pole, electing instead to resell Dish Network. Oh, and if you must have 1 Mbps up, Windstream can actually do that…it just comes with a static IP and costs $120 per month.
The downside of all this? Lots of former Iowa Telecom folks will lose their jobs. The upside? Windstream is buying up companies left and right, absorbing them and becoming a rural supercarrier with enough money to finance large-scale network upgrades while keeping pricing at a sane level. The only competition they’ve wiped out so far is in areas where Windstream was the ILEC and NuVox was a CLEC, which is a VERY small area. Everywhere else, they’ve worked to standardize offerings and upgrade infrastructure so 3/768, $35-per-month DSL is available to lots of people, and 12/768 is available to folks close enough to the DSLAM to get it.
Which is better? Reliable internet from a company that takes several hundred jobs off the market, or high-priced service that’s about the same as Windstream, but favors a local touch over being competitive? It’s a hard choice but I’d honestly LOVE to have my market bought out by Windstream sooner than later. Then again, Verizon is the ILEC and they won’t care about their cpper infrastructure, whereas Windstream does. Heck, I’ll bet WS will buy up all of Verizon’s central Texas/Hill Country markets when everything’s said and done, and that’s fine…that would actually bring a few jobs to the area.
Then again, I’m getting off-topic. One thing though: Windstream in Kerrville, TX has 12M DSL available. That area used to be run by a local telephone company, owned by Valor Telecom, and running at 1.5/512 for DSL service at $50 per month. Which would you rather have?
FWIW, I just checked Consolidated Communications’ website and, after penetrating the zip code wall, found the below pricing for residential and business DSL, respectively (I used Katy as the test town):
Residential (NOT dry-line service; a phone line is required to get these prices)
3 Mbps – $28.95 (available for $14.95 for two years through some type of promo but a full service landline is required)
6 Mbps – $51.95
10 Mbps – $66.95
NOTE: Bandwidth guaranteed on the above plans ranges from 512 kbps to 3 Mbps from what I can tell on the website. In contrast, CenturyLink I believe guarantees 60-80% of the allotted bandwidth.
Business (see above)
3 Mbps – $41.95
6 Mbps – $69.95
10 Mbps – $86.95
In contrast, Windstream’s prices are (looking at quoted web prices…lowest
Residential (dry-line is $5 more)
3 Mbps – $29.99
6 Mbps – $34.99
12 Mbps – $39.99
Business (384 kbps upload for the 1.5 Mbps plan)
1.5 Mbps – $34.99
3 Mbps – $39.99
6 Mbps – $44.99
12 Mbps – $49.99
Static IP versions of the above are $10 extra on 1.5/3 Mbps $15 extra on 6 Mbps and bring the cost of a 12 Mbps plan to $120 per month, though for that price you get 1 Mbps up instead of 768k. Spendy, but better than Time Warner Cable (at least TWC Central TX) for a 10/1 business connection.
You can get 1 meg up without the need for static IPs. 1 meg comes standard with 12 meg down service. A reminder-cable networks are shared. The more people using the bandwidth, the slower the speed is. DSL does not have this limitation, so the prices are not reflecting actual service offerings from the cable companies.