Home » Internet Overcharging » Currently Reading:

AT&T’s “Grandma” Analogy Upsets Grandmothers – They Don’t Want Overcharges Either

Phillip Dampier June 19, 2009 Internet Overcharging 9 Comments

AT&T’s pushback on Rep. Massa’s consumer protection legislation brought quite a reaction when it invoked the vision of “grandma” overpaying for her broadband account.  The Contact form here got a workout well into this afternoon, from upset grandmothers who attack AT&T for presuming they couldn’t spot a raw deal when they saw one:

Irene from Austin:

AT&T thinks they are so smart about getting us to believe them.  I’ve got five grandkids and raised four daughters and one son.  If they couldn’t pull a fast one on me, AT&T sure can’t. God didn’t put me on this earth to be stupid or He wouldn’t have given me a brain.  I don’t use that much Internet myself, but when the kids come over, the computer is the first thing they head for, and they’re doing everything on it. Heaven help people who don’t know about this hot air meter they want to stick us with, because they’ll be blown over when the bill comes. I’m not buying this one bit.

Dee from Thomasville, North Carolina:

I told Time Warner Cable they could come get their boxes and wires out of my house the minute they wanted to run this plan on us. Who do they think they are fooling. We grandmothers know a ripoff when we see one. I’d tell AT&T the same darn thing. Come and get your things out of my house. I’d rather not have it at all than pay even more than I do now.

“AT&T Granny” from Kernersville, North Carolina:

If Ma Bell were still alive, she’d take these greedy people out to the woodshed and set things right.

Ann from Perinton, New York:

I have their economy plan from Time Warner already.  It works just fine.  I don’t believe a word cable companies say. All they know is “price increase” and we just paid them another rate increase in February. I’m insulted by AT&T [that] thinks grandmothers like myself would be dumb enough to fall for their scams.  Now grandfathers might be something else, which is why I pay the bills in this house. When these cable companies want to let me choose what channels I want then tell me about their “fair” plan.  When cable companies and governments come to you with something called a fair plan, you know what to do. We live in New York and know better! Keep doing the right thing.

Nancy in Oklahoma:

I’m 77 years old. I’ve hated the darn phone company for 50 years. It’s always one lie after another with these people. It’s all about the money. How do they expect people to pay the bills they already get? Now these same companies want to get our tax dollars for Obama’s broadband, and then overbill us for more money? Never trust phone companies. They are almost as bad as those crooks in Washington. Not one of my children or grandchildren would work for AT&T. Where are the honest American companies that used to give you a good service at a fair price? I’ve learned a lot of things since my son gave me a computer and brought the Internet to me. But if they start telling me I have to worry about extra fees and meters to watch, I am getting rid of it. The Internet is not a credit card company.




Share

Other stories of interest:

  1. The Tiresome Return of the “Gas & Electric” Analogy

Currently there are 9 comments on this Article:

  1. BrionS says:

    You go grandma!

  2. JM says:

    “But if they start telling me I have to worry about extra fees and meters to watch, I am getting rid of it. The Internet is not a credit card company.”

    Absolutely classic. This demographic clearly understands about capping without any additional “education campaign”.

  3. Smith6612 says:

    It’s great to see even the more elderly people/others on-board and thinking the same way about these capping issues. But yet again, all you really need to find out that this is a ripoff coming at you is some common sense.

  4. jr says:

    AT&T needs to be broken up again

  5. Ken says:

    now be a new service offered in United States in about eight days
    that is a 100% data network that travels through tunneling technology
    the Company signed interconnection agreements with companies like AT&T
    that will allow truly unlimited voice and data with Cap’s ever and no taxes.
    and no contracts.

    you’ll be able to tether for no additional charges AT&T is very smart
    they don’t give away their store into the very last-minute when competition
    forces them to do so.

  6. Adam says:

    Just go’s to show TWC thinks people are stupid. I told my grandmother about this site. She will be making a response shortly =). She currently has TWC and would drop them in a heart beat. I guess being the town “mouth” as she says it has a lot of presence.

  7. Ken says:

    what a lot of people forget is the word grandmother,

    when I think of my grandmother she was 71 years old

    as a grandfather and the grandmother we are now only 50

    does a lot of difference in the wording we definitely are more tech savvy
    than my grandmother was at 71.

    telephone monopolies that’s exactly what they are now squeeze every dime
    another voice connections before they utilize their 100% data network
    I heard they make $.80 for every dollar of voice traffic

  8. John Curotto says:

    We need a publicly funded national fiber optic communications grid NOW!! The scum in the industry have been jerkin’ us around by the short hairs for far too many years. Its a disgrace!

  9. [...] who want consumers to fight amongst themselves while they run to the bank with the money.  Grandma doesn’t want her broadband service limited either, and she’s way too smart to believe a provider promising dramatic savings for less service [...]

Search This Site:

Contributions:

Recent Comments:

  • Sean: A phone company says having customers with working phones is a harmful business model? WTH?...
  • txpatriot: Have any of those mayors asked whether Marriott has built luxury hotels in those depressed areas, or why Cadillac hasn't opened car dealerships in tho...
  • txpatriot: I love it -- this article has NOTHING to do with caps, broadband or anything else related to "Promoting Better Broadband, Fighting Data Caps, Usage-Ba...
  • Bill: It doesn't exactly sound like Verizon is the victim in this article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-kushnick/the-great-verizon-fios-ripoff_b_1...
  • txpatriot: Scott here's another example, this time by a start-up which by definition is somewhat smaller than google: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/23/techno...
  • txpatriot: Phillip, I get that you don't like the VZ co-marketing deal, but can we stick to the subject? The 400 word article you wrote was about CABLE companie...
  • txpatriot: Scott, it takes only one counterexample to disprove a general claim. And surely you're not suggesting that only a company as big as google could ...
  • Scott: I'm afraid I don't share your optimism when you're have to point out a company with a market cap of nearly 200 billion dollars paying a 3rd party to b...
  • Phillip Dampier: In the context of the co-marketing agreement between the cable industry and the nation's biggest wireless operator (Verizon Wireless), building out Wi...
  • txpatriot: Scott, I didn't respond to your comments on barriers to entry. I agree that incumbents have significant advantages as "first-movers". But incumb...
  • txpatriot: "The consumer advocacy group Public Knowledge on Monday criticized an announcement by a group of major cable companies that their customers would now ...
  • George: Schenectady has some of the poorest population in the entire upstate region and they have FiOS. This is a load of bunk. The reason for the lack of exp...

Your Account: